Post Primary - Executive Function and Memory
Age 11 - 16
Introduction
Executive Functions (EF) are a set of cognitive processes that are necessary for the cognitive control of behaviour which facilitates the attainment of chosen goals. These processes enable one to plan, organise, initiate and complete tasks. If a pupil has an effective EF, he / she can generally manage his / her thoughts, attention, behaviours and emotions and learn effectively. EF can be subdivided into three principal areas:
- Shifting (flexibility in thinking, adapting to new situation and unexpected occurrences)
- Inhibition (impulse control, emotional regulation, self-control and staying on task)
- Updating (attention, following complex instructions, adapting to new material, relying on working memory)
There are 5 strands in EF and very often a pupil with literacy difficulties may present with an EF difficulty in any one area and therefore requires additional support and explicit teaching on how to develop these skills and manage them:
- Planning / Prioritising Tasks (includes Task Initiation)
- Organising and Managing Time
- Self-monitoring & Self-control (inhibition)
- Flexible Thinking (shifting)
- Working Memory (updating)
Literacy difficulties can be compounded by a weakness in a specific executive function and very often lead to pupil frustration, which suppresses self-esteem and confidence. A weakness in EF (Executive Function) skills are genuine difficulties and when a school supports a pupil’s executive function difficulties positively, the pupil is more likely to modify his / her behaviour and improve academically.
Planning / Prioritising Tasks
Some pupils, when left to work independently may find it difficult to manage their time to complete tasks, to organise, prioritise, meet assignment deadlines and / or overlook vital details and information. In post primary, the expectation that the pupil works independently. Pupils with literacy difficulties at the post primary stage may struggle to plan and prioritise and are often unable to recognise the specific steps to follow to reach the end goal. They may find it difficult to determine their goal in a lesson or plan the steps required to complete the task and are therefore unable to work independently.
| Impact on Reading | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
| The pupil may be very unsure what it is the teacher is specifically looking for at the end of a lesson |
|
| If reading tasks are too difficult and if pupil has a “can’t do” attitude he / she may procrastinate, be slow to start or complete a task |
|
| A pupil may be unaware of strategies and routines which help him / her access a comprehension passage |
|
| The pupil may be unable to fully understand the questions asked and will need more clarification |
|
| The pupil may doubt or be nervous to give his / her answer or thoughts on a question |
|
| Impact on Writing | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
| The pupil may have processing speed /working memory difficulties and be unable to take accurate notes at a reasonable pace |
|
The pupil may be unsure of how to structure written work, where to begin and how to formally record ideas The pupil may forget what he / she wanted to write |
|
| The pupil may be very unsure of question words |
|
| The pupil may frequently take the homework down incorrectly |
|
| A pupil may be unaware of techniques or by-pass strategies which can support learning |
|
| Impact on Study Skills | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
| The pupil may be unaware of study techniques and strategies to support learning |
|
| The pupil may be unable to retrieve information quickly |
|
Organising & Managing Time
Managing time is an important EF that involves the skill of organising the necessary resources and material to complete a task, estimate the length of the task, plan how to transition from one task to another, and divide time between specific tasks. Often pupils with EF difficulties find the basic requirements of being on time and reading clocks can be a struggle. Added to this complexity is the slow processing speed and working memory difficulties often present in a pupil with literacy differences. This can impact on their time management EF skill and vice versa. Pupils with literacy differences rely heavily upon their working memory which is the foundation that supports all executive functions. Pupils with weak working memory capacity are unable to access present and prior knowledge easily and therefore need strategies to help them access and recall this information.
| Impact on Reading | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
| The pupil may have difficulty with engaging at the start of a task |
|
| The pupil may be unsure of the meaning of words in written passages which is hindering full comprehension of text |
Texthelp Video: How to use Read Write Tools
|
| The pupil may struggle to manage time dedicated to each step of a given reading and comprehension task |
|
| The pupil needs to read and reread information to fully understand it then runs out of time |
Read and Write Quick Reference Guide
|
| The pupil may lose interest / focus frequently |
|
| Impact on Writing | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
| The pupil may have difficulty focusing on initial instructions and maintaining focus throughout activity |
|
| The pupil may have difficulty with preparing first drafts and struggle to organise thoughts and ideas |
|
| Pupil can become frustrated writing ideas down as he / she is struggling with spelling and remembering details |
|
| Impact on Study Skills | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
| The pupil often does not know where to start when asked to use study time in preparation for exams |
|
| Cannot keep important dates and times in mind |
|
| Difficulties organising materials and resources needed to study for different subjects |
|
Self-Monitoring & Self-Control
Self-monitoring is an EF that allows a pupil to manage his / her actions and behaviours and be aware of the consequences. Part of this includes evaluating the process and making necessary changes while working through a task to reach the completed stage. Developing successful and effective learning relies on the pupil thinking about his / her thinking (metacognition),as the pupil thinks about and becomes aware of his / her learning processes. This is an important element for all pupils evaluation of their learning experience will help them to understand and access the materials they are being taught.
If a pupil with literacy differences has been explicitly taught how to self-monitor and self-evaluate the pupil is more likely to display self-control, as they manage behaviours and actions and show responsibility and ownership for work.
| Impact on Reading | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
| The pupil may forget the necessary materials for different classes also for use at home |
|
The pupil may have difficulty making connections and associations within word study
He/ she may struggle to understand unfamiliar vocabulary and language meaning |
An example of a vocabulary list created using Read&Write tools
|
| The pupil may lose his / her place while reading longer passages |
|
| Impact on Writing | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
The pupil may be slow to start an activity or task The pupil may be unsure of what he / she needs to do |
|
| The pupil appears unaware of errors in written work |
Mnemonic for checking dictated sentences (COPS) (Year 8 and Year 9) POWER mnemonic: (Year 10 - Year 14) P - Prepare O - Organise W - Write E - Edit R - Rewrite
|
The pupil may omit sequences in a verbal or written task He / she may be unable to sustain focus He / she may be unable to complete work in given time frame |
Provide a visual reminder of instructions or checklist for the pupil |
| The pupil may be unsure how to make improvements to work that has been returned |
|
| Impact on Study Skills | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
The pupil may be unsure of how to study or revise He / she may be unsure of where to start and become overwhelmed |
|
| The pupil may be unaware of strategies and the style that may help with study |
|
The pupil may be unable to stay on schedule and persevere
He / she may be unable to keep track of assignments, deadlines |
|
| The pupil may be unsure of how to retrieve information to help with revision or how to improve understanding of the material |
|
Flexible Thinking
Being able to think flexibly allows pupils to cope and deal with everyday changes in classroom routines. It also allows pupils to consider other people’s viewpoints; appreciate and accept ranges of opinions or perspectives. Pupils with literacy difficulties or other learning differences such as ASD/ADHD may find it difficult to think flexibly. When teachers help pupils to recognise and identify a change and turn a negative thought into a positive thought this will help develop EF processes. Knowing how to think flexibly can impact on a pupil’s overall understanding of situations which can be transferred to and applied to any form of reading and help a pupil to show understanding.
| Impact on Reading | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
When reading a novel or piece of text, if a pupil does not know how to use flexible thinking to deal with a change or understand a character, or how to overcome a problem and offer a solution, he / she may have ongoing reading comprehension difficulties
The pupil may be unable to “put himself / herself into someone else’s shoes” |
Video: Consolidation Exercise (4:45 mins)
|
| The pupil may find problem-solving difficult |
|
| The pupil may be rigid in thinking and can interpret text literally |
|
| Pupil is unsure how to make predictions or evaluate and compare work |
Printable-Traffic lights (say how you feel about the work)
|
| Impact on Writing | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
| The pupil may be rigid in thinking and cannot think of original ideas to record |
|
The pupil may remain ‘stuck’ at a certain thought process and finds it difficult to move on
Work production is very limited |
|
| Impact on Study Skills | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
The pupil may find it difficult to begin revision
He / she may be unsure of the strategies or resources that could help structure their revision |
|
| Unaware of the strategies that will help him / her learn new knowledge |
|
| The pupil may be unclear of what has been introduced that day and in previous lessons |
|
Working Memory in Post Primary
There are 3 main strands to consider while supporting pupils with working memory difficulties in the post primary classroom:
Monitoring & Planning
- Become aware of a pupil’s working memory capacity when planning
- Monitor the pupil – evaluate and review his / her memory capacity
- Pre-teach new concepts / key facts, if possible, in advance of a new topic so the pupil does not feel overwhelmed
- Consider speed of teaching new content
- Develop routines for practising new content
- Consider the design, layout and format of tasks
Delivery
- Revisit and review prior learning to help the pupil make connections and associations
- Break down tasks and new material into smaller more manageable chunks (Chunking)
- Reduce verbal information and ensure instructions are brief and language used is minimal
- Repeat verbal information and explain instructions (using a step-by-step approach)
- Verbal instructions may be reinforced with visual aids (mind maps, graphic organisers, sequence charts, demonstrations, videos, infographic posters)
- Provide modelling with teacher thinking aloud showing worked examples and giving verbal cues for problem-solving
- Use songs, raps, poems, Mnemonics, acrostics and/or limericks to aid memory
- Use temporary scaffolds such as prompt cards, cue cards, checklists or write key words on whiteboard for reference during tasks
- Allow note taking and use of flashcards (key word on one side and definitions on other)
- Encourage pupil to verbalise each step within a task and/or use a checklist
- Check-in frequently with pupil to ensure he/she understands the steps of the task
- Encourage the pupil to ask questions to ensure he/she understands new content
Review
- Guide the pupil to retell and summarise new content learned
- Encourage peer work (swapping, discussing, and sharing ideas and learning)
- Do allow additional processing time and additional thinking time to respond
- Work alongside your pupil to discover effective memory strategies – what works for him / her (for example, visual cues, illustrations, mnemonics, key word and meaning flashcards)
- Encourage the pupil to adopt a ‘can do’ and an ‘I can’t do this yet’ approach
- Have the pupil focus on understanding rather than learning by heart
- Give constructive feedback – explain to the pupil the learning to refocus on
Working Memory difficulties
| Impact on Reading & Comprehension | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
Loses his / her place when reading, misreads, must restart reading Reads slowly and reads far less than peers in set time limit |
|
The pupil may read and has no idea what the text is about The pupil may processes information at a superficial level and not in-depth |
|
The pupil may have difficulty storing information in the long-term memory to recall The pupil may be unable to verbally retrieve prior knowledge The pupil may struggles to learn vocabulary and its meaning |
|
The pupil may not enjoy reading aloud from class notes / text or the whiteboard He / she may be unwilling to participate in whole class discussions |
|
| Impact on Writing | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
The pupil may have difficulty remembering ideas when planning creative work The pupil may have difficulty remembering details of new learning each day |
|
| The pupil may find it difficult to write down words in a sequence |
|
| The pupil may be unable to take accurate notes at a reasonable pace |
An example of a vocabulary list created using Read&Write tools |
| The pupil may have poorly presented written work |
Texthelp Video: How to use Read Write tools to aid comprehension
|
| Homework may be taken down incorrectly |
|
| Impact on Spelling | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
| The pupils writing show evidence of lots of spelling errors |
|
| Difficulty learning spelling and grammar rules |
People - people eat oreos people like eating Any - ants never yawn, said - Sally Anne is dancing: Printable Resource: Mnemonics for Post Primary Pupils (Topic - Based)
Printable Resource: Mnemonics for Post Primary Pupils (Topic - Based)
|
| Limited vocabulary knowledge | Using Investigative charts will help develop and strengthen vocabulary and understanding of words (both new and known). Investigative charts will enable the pupil to make connections to other words by using, description, function, location, category and similarity type questions |
| Impact on Study Skills | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
| The pupil may struggle with retrieval of information |
|
| The pupil may struggle to stay on schedule and persevere |
|
| Keeping track of assignments, deadlines |
|
| Impact on Organisation & Learning | Recommendations for Reasonable Adjustments |
|---|---|
The pupil may have difficulty:
Keeping track of steps to complete in a task
|
|
| Pupil may not be aware of his / her strengths and weaknesses and what to improve on |
|
| Pupil may find his / her focus and concentration is difficult to maintain |
|
Top Tip: Remember to: Say it, Show it, Model it
Assistive Technology
Assistive Technology
- ‘Text-to-Speech’ and ‘Speech-to-Text’ software in Read and Write, ‘Immersive Reader’, or spoken content in iPad:
Teacher Guidance: Microsoft Dictate Help Sheet
- Access to information in an audio format that the pupil can listen to as often as he / she wishes. Within the Read and Write software the ‘Audio Maker’ could be used to achieve this. When text is highlighted and ‘Audio Maker’ is clicked, the software will automatically turn this into an audio file which can then be stored on the computer. This means that the text can be re-accessed later and listened to on a phone or any device that will play an MP3 file
- When marking digital work, teacher feedback could be recorded orally using ‘Voice Note’ in Read and Write. This would enable the pupil to access it as many times as he / she needs, to understand it
Signposting for Free Professional Learning Modules
The following professional learning modules may be helpful for additional information regarding the strategies recommended in this chapter. They are provided by the Literacy Service and are available through the ‘Children and Young People's Services Professional Learning Programme’, which is hosted on the EA website. The access code to the courses is updated each year and shared with your Principal in September:
- Strategies to Support Pupils with Working Memory Difficulties-Primary & Post-Primary
- Overview of Texthelp ReadWrite Software-Pre-school, Primary & Post-Primary
- Using iPads to Support Pupils with Literacy Difficulties- Everyone
- Dyslexia Friendly Post-Primary Classroom
- An Overview of How Assistive Technology Can Help Pupils with Literacy Difficulties- Pre-School, Primary & Post-Primary
Bibliography and References
Alloway, T. P. (2011) Improving Working Memory: Supporting Children’s Learning. London: SAGE
Alloway T. & Alloway R. (2015) Understanding Working Memory (2nd Edn), London, Sage
Gathercole, S. and Packiam Alloway T, R. (2007): Working Memory - A Classroom Guide
Kelly, K. & Phillips, S. (2023) Teaching Learners with Dyslexia (3rd Edn), London, Sag
McMurray, S. (2020) SEN Resource File: Understanding Memory Difficulties
Packiam Alloway, T. Why schools should pay attention to Working Memory
Rosenshine, B. (2010) Principles of Instruction. Education practice series, Vol:21; 2010, The International Academy of Education